The Best NHL Forwards Lineup of All Time

When debating the greatest players to ever lace up skates, hockey fans inevitably gravitate toward one question: who would make up the ultimate forward group? Building the best NHL forwards lineup of all time requires more than simply listing the highest scorers. It demands balancing generational talent, two-way excellence, chemistry, and the ability to dominate in different eras of the game. From the Original Six days through the high-flying ’80s to today’s speed-and-skill era, the NHL has produced forwards who redefined what’s possible on ice.

This pursuit isn’t just an exercise in nostalgia—it’s about recognizing the players who changed hockey forever. The forwards who earned their place among the greatest hockey players of all time did so through remarkable consistency, clutch performances, and an ability to elevate their teammates. Whether through Wayne Gretzky’s unmatched vision, Gordie Howe’s legendary longevity, or Mario Lemieux’s combination of power and finesse, these players set standards that modern stars still chase.

The first line: assembling the best NHL forwards lineup of all time

Wayne Gretzky: the undisputed centerpiece

No conversation about the best NHL forwards lineup of all time can begin anywhere but with Wayne Gretzky at center ice. “The Great One” doesn’t just hold NHL records—he owns them so completely that they seem untouchable. His 2,857 career points stand 936 ahead of second-place Jaromir Jagr, a gap that represents an entire Hall of Fame career. Gretzky’s 1,963 assists alone exceed any other player’s total points, a statistical anomaly that speaks to his supernatural vision and hockey IQ.

What separated Gretzky wasn’t just skill but his ability to see the game unfold before it happened. He famously used reflections in the glass to track teammates, positioning himself where the play would be rather than where it was. Between 1981 and 1987, he scored more than 200 points in four separate seasons—a benchmark only Mario Lemieux ever approached (199 in 1988-89). Even in today’s NHL, where offensive systems have evolved dramatically, Nikita Kucherov’s 128-point campaign in 2018-19 is considered extraordinary yet falls 72 points short of Gretzky’s single-season best.

His playoff dominance matched his regular-season brilliance. Gretzky’s 122 playoff goals and 382 playoff points remain untouched, with 24 game-winning goals in hockey’s most pressure-packed moments. Four Stanley Cup championships with Edmonton cemented his legacy as not just a points producer but a winner. At 63 years old in 2025, his records continue to tower over the modern game, a testament to an era when one player truly transcended the sport.

Gordie Howe: Mr. Hockey’s timeless excellence

On the right wing of this ultimate first line stands Gordie Howe, whose 32 professional seasons—26 in the NHL—rewrote the definition of longevity and consistency. Howe’s 801 goals and 1,850 points came in an era of six teams and relentless physicality, making his production all the more remarkable. What made “Mr. Hockey” truly special was his ability to dominate through skill while never backing down from physical confrontations, earning respect across generations.

Howe’s durability bordered on mythical. After suffering a skull fracture, broken cheekbone, broken nose, and concussion following a collision with Ted Kennedy in 1950, most players would have considered retirement. Instead, Howe returned to lead the league in scoring the following season and won his first Stanley Cup. At 52 years old, he still managed 41 points—a feat that underscores his adaptability and hockey intellect. He even played alongside his sons Mark and Marty in NHL games, a distinction no other father in hockey history can claim.

The consistency of Howe’s performance is staggering. Excluding his rookie season, he never finished with fewer than 40 points across three decades. He finished in the top five in scoring for 20 consecutive seasons, won six Art Ross Trophies, and appeared in 23 All-Star Games. His plus-518 career rating reflects a player who dominated at both ends of the ice, combining offensive brilliance with defensive responsibility. Howe represents the complete player—one who could score, set up goals, intimidate opponents, and lead by example shift after shift.

Alexander Ovechkin: the greatest goal-scorer

Completing this historic first line on the left wing is Alexander Ovechkin, who recently surpassed Gretzky to become the NHL’s all-time leading goal scorer with over 900 career goals. “The Great Eight” has redefined pure goal-scoring in the modern era, turning his office—the left faceoff circle on the power play—into the most dangerous real estate in hockey. His patented one-timer has become so iconic that every team knows it’s coming, yet few can stop it.

Ovechkin’s nine 50-goal seasons (including nine consecutive seasons to start his career reaching at least 50) demonstrate consistency that rivals any scorer in history. His 326 power-play goals lead all players, showcasing his ability to dominate when games are decided. But Ovechkin isn’t just a finesse player—his 3,400-plus career hits prove he plays a physical brand of hockey that wears down opponents. He consistently ranks among league leaders in shots on goal, embodying Gretzky’s famous quote: “You miss 100 percent of the shots you don’t take.”

What makes Ovechkin’s inclusion alongside Gretzky and Howe so compelling is the chemistry this line would create. Two generational goal-scorers flanking the greatest playmaker ever would produce offensive fireworks. Ovechkin’s willingness to go to the dirty areas, combined with Howe’s physicality and Gretzky’s vision, would create a first line that attacks opponents from every angle—skill, speed, power, and intelligence all converging in one dominant unit.

The second line: Pittsburgh’s powerhouse in the best NHL forwards lineup of all time

Mario Lemieux: super Mario’s brilliance

The second line reunites Pittsburgh Penguins legends, beginning with Mario Lemieux at center. “Super Mario” was the rare combination of 6’4” size with the hands of a magician, capable of impossibly creative plays at full speed. Despite playing only 915 career games due to health challenges including Hodgkin’s lymphoma and chronic back issues, Lemieux still accumulated 1,723 points—a per-game average that trails only Gretzky in NHL history.

Lemieux’s famous “five goals, five ways” game against New Jersey in December 1988 showcased his versatility—scoring even-strength, power-play, shorthanded, penalty shot, and empty-net goals all in one night. He won three Hart Trophies, two Conn Smythe Trophies, and led Pittsburgh to back-to-back Stanley Cups in 1991 and 1992. What makes Lemieux’s career even more remarkable is that he returned after a three-year retirement, becoming the only player-owner in NHL history and mentoring the next generation—including his linemate on this all-time roster.

Advanced statistics suggest that if Lemieux had played as many games as other legends while maintaining his health, he might have challenged Gretzky’s career totals. His 199-point season in 1988-89 remains the closest anyone has come to Gretzky’s 200-point plateau. Lemieux combined elegance with power, using his reach and vision to create plays no one else could conceive. Even at the end of his career, returning at age 35, he still produced at a point-per-game pace, underlining his timeless skill.

Sidney Crosby: the modern maestro

Playing left wing on this line is Sidney Crosby, who learned from Lemieux during his rookie season and has carried the Pittsburgh torch for two decades. “Sid the Kid” has evolved into one of the most complete players in NHL history, winning three Stanley Cups, two Hart Trophies, two Conn Smythe Trophies, and three Olympic gold medals for Canada. His 1,707 career points (and counting) have him ninth all-time as of 2025, with more chapters still to be written.

What sets Crosby apart is his 200-foot game. While many elite forwards focus primarily on offense, Crosby excels on faceoffs (career win percentage over 51%), kills penalties, and shuts down opposing top lines. His hockey IQ mirrors Gretzky’s ability to anticipate plays, making him a coach’s dream. Lemieux himself acknowledged that at age 21, Crosby was already a better player than he had been at the same age—high praise from one of the game’s all-time greats.

Crosby’s ability to elevate his game in crucial moments defines his career. His golden goal for Canada at the 2010 Vancouver Olympics remains one of hockey’s most iconic moments. In 2016 and 2017, he captured back-to-back Conn Smythe Trophies, joining Lemieux as the only Penguins to win playoff MVP honors. Despite numerous concussions that threatened his career, Crosby has maintained elite production well into his late thirties, a testament to his work ethic and dedication to the sport.

Jaromir Jagr: the ageless Czech wonder

Rounding out this all-Penguins second line is Jaromir Jagr on right wing, who spent seven prime seasons alongside Lemieux before embarking on a nomadic career that lasted until age 45. Jagr’s 766 goals rank fourth all-time, while his 1,921 points sit second only to Gretzky. His combination of size, strength, skill, and legendary fitness routines allowed him to compete at elite levels across four decades.

During Pittsburgh’s back-to-back Stanley Cup runs in 1991 and 1992, the Lemieux-Jagr connection was unstoppable. Together over seven seasons, they combined for 1,690 points, terrorizing opposing defenses with their skill and hockey sense. Jagr won five Art Ross Trophies and a Hart Trophy, establishing himself as Europe’s greatest export to the NHL—though Alexander Ovechkin may eventually claim that distinction.

What made Jagr special was his relentless drive to improve. Famous for his grueling off-ice training and dietary discipline, he continued producing into his forties. Even after leaving the NHL, he played several more seasons in the Czech Extraliga, finally retiring at 50. His work ethic and longevity serve as a blueprint for modern players hoping to extend their careers. Reuniting him with Lemieux and adding Crosby creates a second line that combines three generations of Penguins excellence.

The third line: champions and clutch performers in the best NHL forwards lineup of all time

Luc Robitaille: the ultimate draft steal

The third line begins with Luc Robitaille on left wing, a ninth-round pick in 1984 who defied every scouting report to become one of the greatest left wingers in NHL history. Until Ovechkin surpassed him, Robitaille held the distinction as the all-time leading goal-scorer among left wingers with 668 goals. His 1,394 career points came despite constant criticism of his skating ability—proof that hockey sense and scoring instinct can overcome physical limitations.

Robitaille’s 45-goal rookie season announced his arrival, earning him the Calder Trophy. He never experienced a sophomore slump, following up with 111 points. His career-best 125 points in 1992-93 still stands as the most ever by a left winger. For a player drafted 171st overall—behind 11 Los Angeles Kings selections that combined for just 242 career games—Robitaille’s 1,431 games and Hall of Fame career represents one of the greatest steals in draft history.

What made “Lucky Luc” special was his ability to find soft spots in defensive coverage. He possessed an elite wrist shot and positioned himself perfectly around the net, turning half-chances into goals. Over 13 seasons with the Kings, he became synonymous with Los Angeles hockey, eventually returning as team president. His story inspires late-round picks everywhere, proving that determination and skill can overcome early doubts.

Bryan Trottier: the Islanders dynasty engine

Centering this third line is Bryan Trottier, the engine of the New York Islanders dynasty that captured four consecutive Stanley Cups from 1980 to 1983. Trottier’s complete game—scoring, playmaking, defense, physical play—made him the prototype for the modern power forward. His 1,353 points as an Islander lead franchise history, while his plus-449 career rating demonstrates his dominance at both ends of the ice.

Trottier won the Calder, Art Ross, Hart, and Conn Smythe Trophies during his career, checking every box for individual excellence. But his greatest achievements came in team success. During the dynasty years, he produced five consecutive 100-point seasons, consistently elevating his game when championships were on the line. His 183 playoff points with the Islanders and Penguins, including 71 goals, prove his clutch gene. He scored 12 game-winning playoff goals, repeatedly delivering when his teams needed him most.

What made Trottier invaluable was his versatility. He dominated on the power play with 158 career goals and killed penalties effectively with 17 shorthanded goals. Defensively responsible enough to finish second in Selke Trophy voting in 1984, he could match up against opponents’ top lines while still producing offense. His leadership qualities led to him being named Islanders captain, cementing his status as one of hockey’s most respected competitors. Trottier’s consistency and two-way excellence set the standard for championship hockey.

Mike Bossy: the purest goal-scorer

Completing this championship-laden line is Mike Bossy on right wing, whose nine consecutive 50-goal seasons remain an NHL record. Trottier’s longtime linemate, Bossy scored 573 goals in just 752 games—a goals-per-game rate exceeded by only a handful of players in history. His ability to find the back of the net with consistency and precision made him one of the most feared shooters ever.

Bossy achieved the near-mythical “50 goals in 50 games” feat during the 1980-81 season, joining Maurice Richard and Wayne Gretzky as the only players to accomplish it. He scored at least 50 goals every season except one in his career—when he “only” managed 48. This consistency would have continued had a degenerative back condition not forced his retirement at age 30, cutting short what could have been a chase for 800-plus career goals.

In the playoffs, Bossy was even more dangerous. His 85 playoff goals and 160 playoff points helped the Islanders capture four straight Stanley Cups. He scored 17 game-winning goals in the postseason, repeatedly putting his team on his back when elimination loomed. His combination with Trottier created one of the most lethal duos in playoff history. Though his career ended too soon, Bossy’s pure goal-scoring ability earns him a spot on any all-time roster. Reuniting him with Trottier and adding Robitaille’s scoring touch creates a third line that could rival most teams’ top units.

The fourth line: two-way excellence defining the best NHL forwards lineup of all time

Bob Gainey: the defensive standard-bearer

The fourth line emphasizes complete hockey, beginning with Bob Gainey on left wing. Gainey’s four consecutive Selke Trophies as the NHL’s best defensive forward actually inspired the creation of that award in 1978. While his 239 goals and 501 points in 1,160 games don’t match the offensive production of other players on this roster, his defensive mastery and five Stanley Cup championships with Montreal make him indispensable.

Legendary coach Scotty Bowman praised Gainey’s relentless forechecking and tireless backchecking, noting he “could skate forever” without tiring. Montreal Gazette writer Red Fisher called him the hardest worker he ever covered, someone who led by example through pain and determination. Gainey shut down opponents’ best forwards night after night, allowing his offensive teammates to focus on scoring. His plus-167 career rating reflects his impact on winning hockey.

Beyond defense, Gainey provided timely offense. He won the Conn Smythe Trophy in 1979 despite just 16 playoff points, recognition of his complete contributions. Named Canadiens captain in 1982, he wore the “C” for eight seasons, embodying Montreal’s winning tradition. Gainey represents the selfless player every championship team needs—one willing to sacrifice personal statistics for team success. His presence on this fourth line ensures opponents can’t take any shift off.

Steve Yzerman: the captain who epitomized leadership

Centering this line is Steve Yzerman, whose 22 seasons with Detroit define loyalty and leadership. “The Captain” transformed from a 150-point offensive dynamo in his youth to a defensively responsible two-way center who led the Red Wings to three Stanley Cups. His 1,755 career points rank seventh all-time, while his evolution as a player showcases adaptability and maturity.

Yzerman’s 155-point season in 1988-89 demonstrated his offensive ceiling, making him one of only three players to reach 150 points in a season. But his greatest legacy came in his willingness to adjust his game for team success. Under coach Scotty Bowman in the mid-90s, Yzerman embraced two-way responsibilities, becoming elite defensively while maintaining offensive production. This transformation turned Detroit from playoff disappointment into dynasty, capturing Stanley Cups in 1997, 1998, and 2002.

Perhaps no moment better captures Yzerman’s toughness than the 2002 playoff run. Playing on a severely injured knee that limited him to 52 regular-season games, he produced 23 points in 23 playoff games, willing Detroit to another championship. His famous quote—“I’m just happy to be able to contribute”—after playing on one leg exemplifies his selfless approach. Beyond his playing days, Yzerman has excelled as a general manager, building Tampa Bay’s championship team and returning home to rebuild Detroit.

Bobby Clarke: the Broad Street Bullies captain

Completing this formidable fourth line is Bobby Clarke on right wing, captain of Philadelphia’s legendary “Broad Street Bullies” teams that won back-to-back Stanley Cups in 1974 and 1975. Clarke embodied Flyers hockey—tough, skilled, and relentless. His 1,210 points came with 1,453 penalty minutes and a plus-507 rating, showcasing his complete game. Few players combined offensive production with physical intimidation as effectively.

Clarke’s best seasons saw him eclipse 100 points while accumulating over 100 penalty minutes, a rare double achievement. He led the NHL in shorthanded goals twice, scoring 32 career shorthanded tallies while adding 99 power-play goals. His three Hart Trophies and Selke Trophy honor both his offensive excellence and defensive responsibility. Clarke could match up against any opponent while still driving Philadelphia’s offense.

What made Clarke special was his fearless competitive nature. Playing with Type 1 diabetes in an era before modern management techniques, he never used health as an excuse. He battled through injuries and physical punishment, setting the tone for Philadelphia’s tough reputation. His leadership inspired teammates to follow him into battles, earning respect across the league despite his sometimes controversial tactics. Clarke’s presence on this fourth line ensures no opponent can intimidate or outwork this all-time roster.

---

Assembling the best NHL forwards lineup of all time requires balancing multiple eras, styles, and skill sets. This roster combines pure goal-scorers like Ovechkin and Bossy with playmaking wizards like Gretzky and Lemieux. It features complete two-way players such as Yzerman, Trottier, and Clarke alongside defensive specialists like Gainey. From Howe’s three-decade dominance to Crosby’s modern excellence, each player earned their position through sustained greatness.

These 12 forwards represent not just statistical excellence but championship pedigree—combining for over 50 Stanley Cup victories. They transcended their eras, setting standards that current stars still chase. While debates about the best NHL forwards lineup of all time will continue as new generations emerge, the players listed here have carved their names into hockey immortality. Their legacies serve as blueprints for what greatness looks like, reminding us why hockey’s history is so rich and its future so promising.