David Carle Turns Down Maple Leafs to Chase Avalanche Dream

David Carle told the Toronto Maple Leafs during an early conversation that now is not the right time, ending any formal interview process for their head coaching vacancy.

Early Contact and Polite Refusal

The Maple Leafs reached out to Carle shortly after beginning their search to replace Craig Berube. Sources confirm the two sides held one pleasant discussion early in the process. Carle then declined any invitation to a formal interview.

Frank Seravalli reported the exchange directly on X, noting Carle had a good conversation but turned down further steps. David Pagnotta added that Carle explicitly stated the timing was not right. The entire interaction lasted one call and produced no second meeting.

This sequence unfolded in mid-May 2026, days after initial speculation linked Carle to Toronto. The brief contact cooled rapidly once Carle clarified his position.

Singular Focus on Colorado

Carle has made clear through his actions that he intends to leave the University of Denver only for the Colorado Avalanche. Multiple reports tie his future exclusively to that organization once Jared Bednar’s status is resolved following the Avalanche’s Conference Finals sweep.

Bednar would likely find new employment quickly if dismissed, yet Carle appears content to remain patient in Denver. His eight seasons as head coach, beginning May 25, 2018, have produced a 179-74-17 record and NCAA titles in 2022 and 2024.

University of Denver lists Carle, age 36, in his eighth season during 2025-26. He has guided the program to the NCAA Tournament in every full season and four Frozen Four appearances.

Market Context and Limited Options

The Maple Leafs conducted early due diligence on Carle amid a thin market for experienced college coaches willing to jump to the NHL. Other candidates remained available, but Carle’s stance narrowed Toronto’s options immediately.

Carle’s record of success at Denver, including an 83-49-11 NCHC mark, underscores why teams pursued him. His refusal highlights the premium he places on the right fit over any NHL role.

No further conversations between Carle and Toronto have occurred since the initial exchange.