After resigning from the Columbus Blue Jackets 10 weeks after his July 2023 hiring, Mike Babcock drew Oilers interest despite prior allegations.
Reported timeline of interest
The NHL cleared Babcock on August 31 2023 after reviewing his Columbus conduct. The league stated there was no basis to restrict his employment even under the light least favorable to him. Sportsnet’s Elliotte Friedman reported the Oilers would begin formal hiring talks the following week.
General manager Stan Bowman considered other candidates including Dean Evason and Patrick Roy. Those options aligned more closely with the Oilers’ desired coaching profile.
Babcock had not advanced past the first playoff round since 2013. His last Stanley Cup came in 2008 with Detroit.
The reported timeline placed the decision in early September 2023 before training camp.
Player criticism versus organizational rationale
Former players including Mike Commodore Johan Franzen and Daniel Winnik publicly criticized Babcock’s methods. Their accounts described repeated invasions of privacy and public humiliation.
Bowman weighed Babcock’s Cup-winning record against these complaints. The Oilers had already missed multiple windows with McDavid and Draisaitl in the lineup.
A 5-15-0 start under Babcock would have intensified external pressure beyond normal performance scrutiny. The Pacific Division standings would have magnified any early deficit.
Babcock had claimed in July 2023 that his time away allowed him to identify needed changes. The Oilers appeared ready to accept that assurance.
Long-term implications for the franchise
Hiring Babcock carried PR risks that other candidates largely avoided. The combination of past success and recent resignations created a uniquely volatile profile.
Edmonton had explored Bruce Cassidy but Vegas blocked the move. This left Babcock as the available veteran with championship experience.
The decision reflected a win-or-bust mindset for the McDavid era. Any failure would leave management with few remaining explanations.
The episode echoed earlier instances where teams accepted similar trade-offs between results and workplace climate.
Babcock ultimately did not join the Oilers in 2023.
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources
Par Mike Jonderson
Mike Jonderson is a passionate hockey analyst and expert in advanced NHL statistics. A former college player and mathematics graduate, he combines his understanding of the game with technical expertise to develop innovative predictive models and contribute to the evolution of modern hockey analytics.