Penguins eye Simon Nemec in 2026 RFA defenseman sweepstakes

Kyle Dubas could land Simon Nemec in exchange for a first-round pick and an asset, or through a hockey trade of equal value.

Trade framework for Nemec

Dan Kingerski reported that Kyle Dubas seeks players in their early to mid-20s who can contribute right away and remain part of the long-term plan. Simon Nemec of the New Jersey Devils stands out as a right-handed shot who might welcome a fresh start after limited ice time. The Devils may pursue a veteran return to gain immediate help rather than wait for development.

Pittsburgh’s current right-side composition makes the fit less automatic than for other clubs. Nemec would likely require at least a first-round selection plus a secondary piece to pry him loose from New Jersey.

The Penguins hold no pressing cap constraints that would block such a deal. Their priority remains blending youth with the existing core to stabilize the blue line over multiple seasons.

A direct swap of restricted free agents could simplify negotiations if New Jersey values roster balance over draft capital.

Other RFAs on Dubas’s radar

Pavel Mintyukov of the Anaheim Ducks represents another left-handed option whose offensive output dipped in his most recent campaign. Anaheim faces no cap issues yet operates outside true contention, raising questions about whether Mintyukov merits a first-round price tag.

Michael Kesselring stands 6 feet 5 inches tall for the Buffalo Sabres and brings elite skating despite modest point totals. His size and mobility align with modern defensive requirements.

Olen Zellweger also from Anaheim offers a lower-cost reclamation opportunity that would not demand first-round compensation. Each of these four names gives Dubas distinct profiles to evaluate before the July 1 restricted free-agent window.

Broader market for Nemec

James Nichols outlined eight clubs that could pursue Nemec, including the San Jose Sharks who lack depth on the back end and might package Collin Graf. The St. Louis Blues could explore a Jordan Kyrou-centered swap while the Montreal Canadiens weigh an RFA exchange given their own pending deals.

Nashville and Seattle hold cap flexibility or organizational gaps on the right side that a Nemec acquisition might fill. Toronto lacks younger right-shot options, and Vancouver seeks additional young blueliners. Minnesota enters the conversation only if Quinn Hughes negotiations stall.

Calgary, the Islanders, Boston and Chicago round out the list of teams monitoring the situation without immediate cap or roster urgency.

A completed deal would reshape New Jersey’s timeline while handing Pittsburgh a 22-year-old right-handed defender ready for top-four minutes.