The Toronto Maple Leafs parted ways with head coach Craig Berube on Wednesday, a move announced by new general manager John Chayka just days after he took over from Brad Treliving, who was fired on March 30.[1][2] Berube still had two years left on his contract, but the Leafs’ fall out of the playoff race prompted the change. Chayka emphasized that the firing was “less an evaluation of him and more a chance for an organizational shift and fresh start.”[3]
With the NHL draft approaching and the top pick potentially bringing Gavin McKenna to Toronto, Chayka plans to cast a wide net in the coaching search.[4] The organization seeks someone to maximize stars like Auston Matthews while developing youth. Here are four strong candidates who fit the bill.
Bruce Cassidy
Bruce Cassidy stands out as a win-now coach for the Maple Leafs. At 60, the former Vegas Golden Knights bench boss brings proven success, including a Stanley Cup in 2023 and the Jack Adams Award in 2020 with Boston.[5] He also assisted Team Canada to gold at the 4 Nations Face-Off and silver at the Olympics.
Vegas recently fired Cassidy, making him available amid a quiet market.[6] The Golden Knights even blocked Edmonton from interviewing him, highlighting his demand. For Toronto, outside the Pacific Division, permission might not be an issue.[7]
Cassidy’s systems emphasize structure and playoff grit, ideal for the Leafs’ retool. His Bruins teams consistently contended, much like what Chayka envisions.
- Stanley Cup winner (2023 with Vegas)
- Jack Adams Trophy (2020)
- Multiple deep playoff runs
If immediate results are priority, Cassidy tops the list. Chayka must move fast, as other teams circle.[4]
His experience with high-pressure markets like Boston prepares him for Scotiabank Arena. Toronto’s core could thrive under his veteran guidance.
David Carle
David Carle, 36, boasts the hottest resume among young coaches. At the University of Denver, he’s built a dynasty with three NCAA titles in four years, including recent Frozen Four success.[8] He also guided Team USA to gold at the 2024 and 2025 world juniors.
Carle’s player development shines, perfect for Toronto’s mix of stars and prospects. A year ago, he extended with Denver, but NHL interest persists, especially with the Leafs’ draft capital.[9]
Transitioning like potential top pick Gavin McKenna, Carle could bridge college to NHL. His committed systems demand buy-in, suiting Matthews and young talent.
- Three NCAA championships (recent dynasty)
- World junior gold medals (2024, 2025)
- Proven with elite youth
Selling full control at a marquee franchise might lure him. Stability at Denver is appealing, but Toronto offers Cup potential.
Chayka values fresh voices; Carle’s upside aligns with an organizational reset.
Manny Malhotra
Manny Malhotra, 45, knows Toronto from his playing and assistant days. Now head coach of the AHL’s Abbotsford Canucks, he led them to the 2025 Calder Cup, boosting his profile.[10]
Renowned for positive reinforcement and preparation, Malhotra excels in development. His son Caleb eyes top-five draft status, adding personal ties, though Toronto would need trades.
Abbotsford’s extension through 2026-27 shows commitment, but NHL allure beckons. His style fosters improvement across rosters.
- Calder Cup champion (2025)
- Former Leafs player/assistant
- Player development expert
Malhotra’s market familiarity gives an edge. As he grows, so could the Leafs’ core. Following the firing of GM Brad Treliving, his internal appeal strengthens.
Vancouver values him post-championship, but Toronto’s spotlight tempts.
John Gruden
John Gruden, 55, offers in-house continuity as Toronto Marlies coach. He guided Hamilton Bulldogs to an OHL title in 2018 and assisted with the Islanders and Bruins.
Gruden knows the Leafs’ prospects intimately, having coached Auston Matthews and Joseph Woll in USA Hockey’s NTDP. Reviving Matthews’ scoring is key.[11]
The Marlies reached North Division finals this year, showcasing his playoff chops. Post-Berube, Gruden addressed readiness for NHL head roles.[12]
- Coached Matthews in NTDP
- OHL championship (2018)
- AHL playoff success
An internal hire makes sense amid change. Chayka praised the process in his media availability.[13]
Gruden’s familiarity eases transition. The recent GM search highlighted organizational continuity.
The Leafs face a pivotal summer with the top draft pick and playoff drought. Chayka’s wide search promises options blending experience and innovation.[3] Selecting among Cassidy’s pedigree, Carle’s youth, Malhotra’s development, or Gruden’s familiarity could spark contention. Expect quick movement as the market heats up—what it means for the Cup chase starts now.
Frequently Asked Questions
Par Mike Jonderson
Mike Jonderson is a passionate hockey analyst and expert in advanced NHL statistics. A former college player and mathematics graduate, he combines his understanding of the game with technical expertise to develop innovative predictive models and contribute to the evolution of modern hockey analytics.