Jeff Petry’s early season struggles cast shadow over Florida Panthers’ defensive depth

Jeff Petry, the 37-year-old defenseman brought in on a one-year deal worth $775,000, has struggled in his transition to South Florida. Through his first 16 games with the Florida Panthers in the 2024-25 season, Petry has managed just five assists, with a minus-3 rating and an average ice time of 14:46 per game. Before joining Florida, he appeared in 44 regular-season games with the Detroit Red Wings, recording eight points (1 goal, 7 assists). Bleacher Report noted concerns about Petry’s high-leverage play and possession metrics, stating that his Corsi ratings are in the 30s after the first month. The Panthers’ defensive woes are part of a broader issue, as they allowed the fifth-most goals per 60 minutes early in the season.

Petry’s limited power-play usage (about 1:16 per game) and reduced role reflect the coaching staff’s skepticism about his offensive contributions. At 37, the veteran’s decline appears to be an overarching trend in his game, not solely a function of system or teammates. Despite 981 career NHL games and a history of offensive contributions, Petry’s current metrics suggest a mismatch between the player Florida hoped to add and his present form.

The Panthers entered the season as defending champions, relying on their depth to repeat. Petry’s struggles have prompted broader questions about Florida’s defensive depth and the ability of the third pairing to hold up under pressure, potentially forcing top-four defensemen to shoulder more minutes. The situation also raises considerations about roster flexibility, potential replacements, and internal development options within the organization as they aim to defend their title.